| Paul Newman | Butch Cassidy | |
| Katharine Ross | Etta Place | |
| Henry Jones | Bike Salesman | |
| George Furth | Woodcock | |
| Ted Cassidy | Harvey Logan | |
| Donnelly Rhodes | Macon |
| Robert Redford | The Sundance Kid | |
| Strother Martin | Percy Garris | |
| Jeff Corey | Sheriff Bledsoe | |
| Cloris Leachman | Agnes | |
| Kenneth Mars | Marshal | |
| Jody Gilbert | Large Woman |