| Taylor Russell | Emily | |
| Alexa Demie | Alexis | |
| David Garelik | Ryan | |
| Joshua Brockington | Stan | |
| Renée Elise Goldsberry | Catharine | |
| Albert Link | Minister |
| Kelvin Harrison Jr. | Tyler | |
| Bill Wise | Coach Wise | |
| Justin R. Chan | Chang | |
| Krisha Fairchild | English Teacher | |
| Sterling K. Brown | Ronald | |
| Clifton Collins Jr. | Bobby |