| Susan Hayward | Barbara Graham | |
| Virginia Vincent | Peg | |
| Wesley Lau | Henry L. Graham | |
| Lou Krugman | John R. 'Jack' Santo | |
| Bartlett Robinson | District Attorney Milton | |
| Joe De Santis | Al Matthews |
| Simon Oakland | Edward S. 'Ed' Montgomery | |
| Theodore Bikel | Carl G.G. Palmberg | |
| Philip Coolidge | Emmett Perkins | |
| James Philbrook | Bruce King | |
| Gage Clarke | Attorney Richard G. Tibrow | |
| John Marley | Father Devers |